Sacredness of the human body inspires Catholic burial guidelines
The dignity of our bodies is not lost after death and must be honored accordingly
Eight men carried an olive green casket to the waiting gravesite at Resurrection Cemetery on a clear, cold November morning. Fallen leaves swirled in the wind around the headstones as their brother in Christ, William “Bill” Duffy, was laid to rest.
Father Mike Giesler, a priest of Opus Dei, led the small group gathered around the grave in final prayers for Duffy, a longtime Opus Dei numerary.
The celebration of a Catholic funeral Mass and rite of committal help orient those left behind to the promise of eternal life, said Norbert Carballo, director of the Wespine Study Center and a fellow Opus Dei numerary.
“We know this is a temporary departure, and we will be with him again in heaven someday,” Carballo said.
The month of November is a time for Catholics to “memento mori” — remember our deaths — including what happens to our bodies after we die and why.
To do that well, we have to take a step back and think about who the human person is, said Father Peter Fonseca, pastor of Seven Holy Founds Parish in Affton and director of continuing formation for priests who holds a doctoral degree in health care ethics.
“The human person is a body-soul composite. The two are intimately connected. The soul is not trapped in the body, as a dualist would say; the goal of life is not the escape of the soul from the body,” he said. “The two are intimately connected, and so there is a sacredness to the body. It’s not just a part; it is who we are.”
We were created by God in His own image and likeness. And, from the moment of our baptism, we become temples of the Holy Spirit as God comes to dwell in our bodies, Father Fonseca added.
“There’s a sacredness to the body that remains even after the soul has departed the body with death,” he said. “And we want to make sure that there is the proper reverence and respect shown to the body.”
On a communal level, we remain members of the body of Christ united with the rest of the faithful even after death.
“We’re reminded about the sacredness of the body not just in death, but the sacredness of all the bodies around us and the way we’re called to treat them,” he said, “but also our obligation to pray for those who have died, that they might be received into eternal life.”
In that spirit, the Church has established guidelines for how bodies are treated after death.
Burial
The burial of a person’s intact body is the Church’s preferred way to bury the dead.
“There’s something about burying the body which brings with it that recognition of its sacredness of who the person is, and also a reminder of the future resurrection of the body,” Father Fonseca said. “Sure, we know the body will decay eventually, but we’re liturgical people — gathering at the funeral home and paying one’s respects to the body, there’s prayers and reminder of the resurrection of the body and there’s something very visual about still seeing the body there.”
During a funeral Mass, a pall is placed over the casket and it is blessed while the body is present. “Just as our bodies were brought into the church as infants for the first time at baptism, at the end of our life, our family brings our body into church one last time to send us off into eternal life,” he said.
Green burials are an option for people who are looking to lessen their environmental footprint, Father Fonseca said. A green burial typically involves burying the body in a simple wood casket or wrapped in a shroud, without having it first preserved.
Cremation
According to the Church’s code of canon law, “The Church earnestly recommends that the pious custom of burying the bodies of the deceased be observed; nevertheless, the Church does not prohibit cremation unless it was chosen for reasons contrary to Christian doctrine” (Canon 1176).
Cremation is a practice that the Church has allowed throughout history in response to circumstances, such as during the bubonic plague in the Middle Ages, Father Fonseca said. In other times, different sects have arisen that see the body as merely a trapping for the soul, an untruth the Church fights against.
“We want to make sure (cremation) is not seen as a disrespect of the body, that it’s not seen as: the body is bad, and so we have to dispose of the body in this way,” Father Fonseca said.
In his experience, lower cost is often a reason families choose cremation. As long as there’s still a desire to respect the body, the remains are interred in a sacred space and there’s no lack of faith in the resurrection of the body, the Church recognizes it as a morally acceptable option, he said.
Cremains must be kept together and buried or interred in a sacred place like a columbarium or mausoleum, not kept in an urn in a home or scattered. People who want to keep ashes of their loved one usually have good intentions, Father Fonseca said, but it comes back to the importance of being laid to rest in a sacred place accessible by the faithful.
“This is a place where the body is going to await the resurrection,” he said. “It’s a place where family and friends can come and pray for the repose of the soul.”
The Church distinguishes between methods of cremation, however. Alkaline hydrolysis, a relatively new cremation process for human bodies, is often touted as an environmentally-friendly version of cremation in which a chemical process of water and potassium hydroxide or sodium hydroxide reduces a body to components of sterile liquid and bone. The liquid is typically disposed of through the sewer system, while the bones are pulverized into ash and returned to the family.
While the universal Church has not made a ruling on the morality of alkaline hydrolysis, Father Fonseca said, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops opposes it. In the Archdiocese of St. Louis, then-Archbishop Robert J. Carlson issued a 2018 memo directing Catholics to avoid the process.
The issue is with the way the remaining liquid is disposed of down the sewer system, which does not show proper reverence for the sacredness of the human body, Father Fonseca said.
Body and organ donation
The Church sees organ donation as a good gift, Father Fonseca said.
“When I donate an organ, I am giving a gift of myself. There’s an invitation to Christ, who lays down His life,” he said.
The donation of one’s body for scientific research is also permitted as long as the body is respected and the remains are either returned to family for burial or interred afterward, he said. For example, Saint Louis University’s body gift program cremates the bodies after the research is finished and buries the cremains in a plot at Sts. Peter and Paul Cemetery.
At SLU’s annual memorial service in memory of those who donated their bodies to science, students from the medical school and health care areas of study spoke about the donors’ impact.
“As a student and a teaching assistant, I often like to brag that I get to study the best thing on earth, God’s greatest miracle: the human body,” master’s student Jessica Pillatzki said. “We are made in the image of God, and this often reminds me of that. I get to spend every day looking at God’s face, seeing every single detail and care He took as He created us.”
Pillatzki said that while studying a body, she notices the slight differences in anatomy and clues to conditions that affected the person during their lifetime, a reminder of the unique gift each person was.
“As I have worked with our donors, I too see God’s reflection in them, a glimpse into their lives and into their souls,” she said. “May their memories remain with families and friends here today. Thank you for entrusting us and allowing us to study that great miracle.”
The resurrection of the dead
Catholics profess that we “look forward to the resurrection of the dead” every time we recite the Nicene Creed.
“By death the soul is separated from the body, but in the resurrection God will give incorruptible life to our body, transformed by reunion with our soul. Just as Christ is risen and lives forever, so all of us will rise at the last day” (Catechism of the Catholic Church 1016).
We see this belief in the resurrection of the body in Scriptures and in the earliest days of the Church, Father Fonseca said. The exact means and methods? That’s for God to know.
“As a person of faith, it’s not really a question I overly contemplate. How does God create out of nothing?” he said. “There’s all kinds of beauties and marvels of God’s creation that are beyond my comprehension. That doesn’t mean they’re not true. They’re certainly true. In some sense, the healthier approach is to sit there and marvel.”